Coming into 9-1-1 season 8, episode 18, the 118 were all dealing with their own dilemmas and conflicts: Chimney still felt responsible for Bobby’s death, Athena couldn’t even look at Chimney, Hen didn’t want to accept the captaincy, Eddie was offered a job in El Paso, and Buck was spiraling out of control due to his bereavement. One of 9-1-1’s intense disasters— a 19-story building collapse— forces the 118 (and Athena) to face not only each other but also themselves. Even after structural collapse leaves unlikely pairs trapped together, the team works together to save everyone on-site.
Following Bobby’s burial in 9-1-1 season 8, episode 16, Athena was able to navigate her grief with one notable exception: every time she saw Chimney, she’d be filled with rage. Athena knew Bobby’s death wasn’t Chimney’s fault, but her overwhelming grief caused her to displace her emotions. Fortunately, 9-1-1 season 8’s finale sequestered the two in the basement when the building collapsed and forces them to work together. Though Athena was rigid as soon as he arrived, she helped Chimney as they tend to two civilians, one of whom being Graeme (Scott Roach), Athena’s nuisance vigilante.
Throughout the overarching emergency, Graeme had an abdominal injury that he was hiding from Athena and Chimney to prioritize the other civilians. Similar to Bobby, he prematurely accepted his death and planned to sacrifice himself— but the 118 intervened. Once Chimney saves Graeme’s life and the 118 gets them to safety, Athena lets go of her resentment. Initially, Chimney claimed that saving Graeme was a team effort, to which Athena said Bobby always talked about Chimney underestimating himself. She went on to tell Chimney that Bobby would be proud of him, and the two share a hug.
9-1-1 season 8’s finale proved that Chimney and Athena’s reconciliation was lasting when the police sergeant shows up to meet Chimney and Maddie (Jennifer Love Hewitt) at the hospital. Every member of the 118 and their families crowded around the bed, but Athena cut through the crowd to hold the newborn. In a bittersweet moment, Chimney and Maddie’s second baby in 9-1-1 was given a heroic namesake. As Chimney announces:
“Athena… say hello to Robert Nash Han.”
One of 9-1-1’s most contentious decisions after Bobby’s death was bringing back Vincent Gerrard (Brian Thompson) to lead the 118. Even though 9-1-1 explained Gerrard would be Bobby’s replacement temporarily, having the former antagonist be called “Cap” felt like an affront to the team. Immediately, eyes turned to the surviving members of the 118 to determine who would be Bobby’s successor. Hen was the obvious choice, since she acted as Bobby’s unofficial lieutenant and was acting captain of the 118 on numerous occasions. Yet, Hen told Athena she didn’t want to be Bobby’s successor in 9-1-1 season 8, episode 17.
Arguably the biggest question heading into the 9-1-1 season 8 finale was where Eddie would be at the end of the hour. Previously, 9-1-1 implied Eddie belongs in Texas, but both he and his son, Christopher (Gavin McHugh), were noticeably happier in LA. Despite all the signs pointing towards Eddie choosing to stay, 9-1-1 season 8, episode 18 opened with a goodbye party, revealing Eddie chose El Paso in between episodes. After joining the 118 for the rescue, Eddie started looking for a flight to Texas before he’s even taken his turnouts off. Thankfully, Chimney’s speech dissuaded him from leaving.
If Chimney does become captain in 9-1-1 season 9, it’s possible that Eddie could become a paramedic for the 118 alongside Hen, ending his and Buck’s 7-season partnership. That would allow Ravi to stay on 118’s A-Shift but considerably shake up the team dynamic. Eddie and Christopher blissfully ended on good terms in the 9-1-1 season 8 finale, but only time will tell if the father and son’s tumultuous relationship is fully healed.
The 118 has been 9-1-1’s found family since the beginning, but they faced many obstacles throughout season 8. The season began with Bobby apart from the 118, and though it technically ended the same way, Bobby’s legacy will live on within the LAFD. 9-1-1’s first main character death was a major turning point for the series, but the memory of Captain Nash will live on in perpetuity, whether it’s a quick comment (like Eddie mentioning Bobby taught him they “always have a choice”) or a purposeful zoom-in on a picture of Peter Krause’s face.
The pain of Bobby’s shocking death may never fade, but 9-1-1 at least offered the consolation that Athena and the rest of the ensemble cast have each other to lean on. 9-1-1 has never been about realism or cheap tricks, but Bobby’s death speaks to the danger of the firefighting profession, even if many still view it as a needless plot twist. Though it pains me to say, the series inevitably had to turn to the next chapter, and Bobby retiring likely wouldn’t pack the same punch.
While the 9-1-1 season 8 finale brought everyone together again, that doesn’t mean there were no conflicts awaiting the 118 in season 9. For every storyline that was conclusively resolved in “Seismic Shifts,” there was one that still needed a satisfying conclusion. 9-1-1 has to explain why it made an entire subplot about Buck potentially having feelings for Eddie just to ignore it later on. Now that Athena has sold her and Bobby’s house, it’s unclear where she’s going or what she plans on doing in 9-1-1 season 9. There is still so little known about Ravi, but he deserves character development.
Hopefully, there will be no near-death experiences in 9-1-1 until the audience has recovered from Bobby’s death— or at least come to terms with it enough to move forward. There are plenty of ways to raise the stakes without killing anyone else, and 9-1-1 needs to return to a healthy mix of fun and fear. Nothing is certain about the future of 9-1-1 past season 9, so all eyes will be on the first-responder drama for a make-or-break season.
Enjoy ScreenRant's primetime coverage? Click below to sign up for our weekly Network TV newsletter (make sure to check "Network TV" in your preferences) and get the inside scoop from actors and showrunners on your favorite series.
Brittany Cartwright has always been a staple in the reality TV scene, known for her larger-than-life personality on The Valley. But while fans adore her on-screen antics, her recent fashion choices have left many scratching their heads. From questionable color ...
It’s been a while since we’ve heard any news about The Real Housewives of New York. Following the animosity between some of the cast members last season, some fans are wondering who will be asked back for Season 16. Or will ...
Hulu’s reality-TV universe is getting Bravo-level messy. A crossover between the casts of Vanderpump Villa and The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives has ended with accusations of infidelity, assault, and harassment. You probably know of MomTok, the faith-based content-creator group in Utah that imploded over “soft ...
ANew York Jets offensive lineman is finally getting some long-overdue respect. Jonathon Macri of Pro Football Focus listed Alijah Vera-Tucker as the “most underrated player” on the Jets roster heading into 2025. “Vera-Tucker hasn’t played more than 432 snaps in a season since his 2021 ...
9-1-1 actor Oliver Stark has condemned the homophobic backlash that followed his character’s gay kiss in a surprise storyline aired to mark the show’s 100th episode. *Spoilers for the latest episode of 9-1-1 follow – you have been warned* Thursday’s episode (4 April) of the US drama series ...