The 2019 draft was a good one for the NHL and for the Montreal Canadiens. The Habs had the 15th overall pick and couldn’t believe their eyes when they saw that USNTDP’s scorer Cole Caufield was sliding because of his small size. Fans watching the draft were telling themselves not to get too excited because, sure, his slide would stop before the 15th overall pick. Still, the Florida Panthers selected Spencer Knight, and the Philadelphia Flyers opted for Cam York, allowing Montreal to grab Caufield with the 15th overall pick.

Looking back at this draft today and how productive some players have been, chances are, a few teams wouldn’t have drafted the way they did. It’s fascinating to compare the top 10 picks with the top 10 scorers today; the Canadiens are one of the winners of that draft. Six years later, they have three of the top 10 scorers.

Here are the top 10 picks of that draft:

1. Jack Hughes – New Jersey Devils

2. Kaapo Kakko – New York Rangers

3. Kirby Dach – Chicago Blackhawks

4. Bowen Byram – Buffalo Sabres

5. Alex Turcotte – Los Angeles Kings

6. Moritz Seider – Detroit Red Wings

7. Dylan Cozens – Buffalo Sabres

8. Philip Broberg – Edmonton Oilers

9. Trevor Zegras – Anaheim Ducks

10. Vasily Podkolzin – Vancouver Canucks

Interestingly, seven of the first 10 picks are no longer with the teams that drafted them. Kakko is now in Seattle, Dach is in Montreal, Byram is in Buffalo (although that may change soon), Cozens is in Ottawa, Broberg has signed an offer sheet to join the St. Louis Blues, Zegras is now with Philadelphia, and Podkolzin is also in St. Louis.

It’s not necessarily because they all flopped; six of those ten players are also part of the top 10 point scorers of the draft. One of the three who stayed with his original team, however, isn't. Without further ado, here’s the breakdown of the top 10.

1. Jake Hughes – New Jersey Devils

Hughes needed a few seasons, but he soon became something other than Quinn Hughes’ little brother. In his third full season in the league, he scored 68 points and hasn’t looked back since. Now, in 368 games, he has 351 points. By the time his career is over, he’s likely to be more than a point-per-game player. New Jersey has no reason to regret its pick and would do it all over again.

2. Matthew Boldy

He didn’t make the top ten at the draft, but he was pretty close, being drafted 12th overall by the Minnesota Wild. Now, he’s second in points from that draft class with 244 points in 285 games. Unsurprisingly, he remains with the team that initially selected him and turned out to be a much better pick than Kakko, who went second overall.

3. Cole Caufield

As mentioned earlier, he was the Canadiens’ pick at 15th overall, but in the top scorer standings, he advanced to third overall with 219 points in 287 games. Funnily enough, he’s now a teammate of the original third pick, Dach, and he has 98 points more than Dach, despite having played just 18 more games than Dach did. Dach made the jump right into the NHL, while the Canadiens instructed Caufield to stay in the NCAA for an extra year, and it looks like it was the right decision.

4. Dylan Cozens

The news is that Senator's center has put up 213 points in 362 games, all of which were played with a struggling Buffalo side, but the last 21, which is how long he’s been in Ottawa. He’s fared much better than original fourth-overall pick Byram, who’s got 110 points in 246 games split between the Colorado Avalanche and the Sabres.

5. Trevor Zegras

Say what you will about Zegras, but he does possess some offensive skills. His 186 points in 268 games make him the fifth-best scorer in the draft, two spots higher than where he was initially drafted. Meanwhile, the fifth overall pick, Turcotte, is nowhere to be seen on the top 10 scorers list; he’s only put up 29 points in 100 games with the Kings, and there’s room for improvement. This year was the first season he spent solely in the NHL.

6. Moritz Seider

Aside from Hughes, Seider is the only player who occupies the same rank in scoring as he was in the draft. The defender went sixth overall and has gathered 180 points in 328 games and a Calder Trophy to boot. The highest-scoring defenseman in the draft, the Wings really can’t complain.

7. Kaapo Kakko

The Rangers picked him second overall and eventually gave up on him, trading him to the Seattle Kraken for Will Borgen and a couple of draft picks (third round and sixth round in 2025). Still, his 161 points are the seventh-best total in the draft, and he achieved them in 379 games, the highest total of games played since the draft, indicating that he has remained healthy.

8. Matias Maccelli

The left winger was only drafted in the fourth round by the now-defunct Arizona Coyotes, but he somehow managed to become the eighth highest scorer in the draft with 130 points in just 224 games. He heard he was traded this Summer while playing a round of golf with friends. One of them saw news of the deal on the course and started screaming in excitement. Chances are, he’s one happy camper right now.

9. Alex Newhook

The second Canadiens player on the list was the 16th overall pick in the draft. He was claimed by the Colorado Avalanche right after the Habs grabbed Caufield, so he’s higher in the top ten list, which is a good thing. Still, in 296 games played, he’s gathered 126 points. That’s 0.43 points per game, which is quite a drop from Maccelli, who has a 0.58 average. This past season, Newhook put up just 26 points in 82 games, which is a significant regression compared to his 34 points in just 55 games the year before, but to be fair, he spent a lot of time on a line with Patrik Laine, who’s not that efficient at even strength.

10. Kirby Dach

Last and least (at least in terms of points), Dach, who was drafted third overall, falls to number 10 in the top 10 in points. In 269 games, he has 121 points, trailing Newhook by just five points, despite the latter having played 27 more games. If you look at it that way, it makes you wonder why Dach is getting so much flak compared to Newhook, and the answer there is probably because the expectations as to the capacity of being that top-two center were much higher towards Dach.

Still, it’s pretty remarkable that the Canadiens have three of the top 10 scorers of that draft, and if Newhook and Dach live up to their potential, it will be even more impressive. In a contract year and after having been publicly criticized at the end of season media availability, Dach should be eager to prove that he can be that second-line center and finally stay healthy. As for Newhook, a lot will depend on how the lines shake up, but in any case, they will be two forwards to keep an eye on this upcoming season.