Carrie Underwood surprised fans with a rare makeup-free selfie, and many are now calling for her to embrace a more natural look.

The American Idol judge, who recently stepped in to replace Katy Perry, shared the candid snap on Instagram while preparing for the latest episode of the singing competition.

In the photo, the country star looked relaxed in a casual T-shirt, sipping wine in her kitchen with freshly baked bread on the counter.