Colts Advised to 'Panic' Over Quarterback Situation

Regardless, Colts general manager Chris Ballard feels the competition between Richardson and Jones will be enough to guarantee some sort of success in 2025. Some analysts don't feel the same. Moe Moton with Bleacher Report thinks the Colts shouldn't feel comfortable with those two options.

"Indianapolis Colts general manager Chris Ballard and head coach Shane Steichen should be on a full-tilt panic alert with their quarterback room," wrote Moton. "The Colts may have to choose a starter between the better of two subpar quarterbacks, which doesn't bode well for the offense. [Jason] Bean, an undrafted second-year player out of Kansas, is a non-factor."

Moton placed the Colts at a 10 out of 10 on the "panic meter", giving a cause for concern in Indianapolis. Neither Richardson nor Jones have proven they can win consistently or provide average quarterback play.

Richardson finished the 2024-25 season with a 47.7% completion rate while throwing for eight touchdowns and 12 interceptions. As a passer, the numbers are ugly. As a runner, both Richardson and Jones have proven to be capable of handling dual-threat action.

Richardson ran for 499 yards and six touchdowns in 11 starts last season. In 2022, which was Jones's best season on the ground, he ran for 708 yards and seven touchdowns in 16 starts.

If the two can utilize their legs without risking injury, the Colts' offense could find success early in the year. Injuries have been an issue for both quarterbacks, bringing another layer of worry to the table. Keeping the same guy in the huddle will be as it helps the entire team settle down and find their rhythm.