Spencer Rattler faces a pivotal preseason as the New Orleans Saints evaluate their quarterback options for the 2025 NFL season. With the starting role within reach, Rattler must prove he can lead the team, knowing a misstep could push him to the bottom of the depth chart.
Rattler has taken the majority of first-team reps during training camp, a clear indication that he is leading the competition against Tyler Shough and Jake Haener. This consistency marks a shift in New Orleans’ QB rotation, where Rattler had previously alternated roles. Analysts note that his performance in preseason games could solidify his position or leave the door open for Shough to overtake him.
The stakes are high, as Rattler’s NFL journey has been marked by mixed results. After stepping in for Derek Carr last season, he delivered 1,317 passing yards with four touchdowns and five interceptions. While his experience gives him an edge, the Saints’ new coaching staff, which did not draft him, may have a shorter leash if his preseason performances falter.
Shough, a second-round rookie, represents a credible challenger. Though less experienced, his draft pedigree and potential offer New Orleans a long-term option. If Rattler stumbles during the team’s tough opening schedule, the coaching staff may quickly pivot to Shough for a spark. This competition remains fluid and could extend well into the regular season.
NFL Analysis Explains Why New Orleans Saints’ Spencer Rattler Faces a Lot of Pressure Ahead of 2025 Season
Rattler has plenty at stake as the new season inches closer. This is detailed more in an analysis by Moe Moton for Bleacher Report.
Rattler has more at stake in the preseason than Shough, who likely has a future with the team as an early-round pick. Whether the rookie wins the battle or not, he may eventually have another chance to win the job because of his draft pedigree.
Rattler, who was a fifth-round pick last year, must make the most of his opportunity, or else, he could fall to the bottom of the depth chart within the next year.
Remember, the Saints have a new coaching staff that didn’t draft Rattler, and he’s competing against Shough, who has more perceived upside because of his draft status.
NFL experts highlight that preseason is critical for players like Rattler, who are fighting to define their roles. A strong showing could not only secure him the starting job but also position him as a key part of New Orleans’ future. Failing to impress, however, could relegate him to a backup role or worse.
For Rattler, the preseason is more than a competition; it is a defining moment. Whether he rises to the occasion or fades under pressure will determine his NFL trajectory.