Saints QB Competition: Tyler Shough Outplays Spencer Rattler, but New Orleans' Outlook Remains Bleak

As the New Orleans Saints gear up for the 2025 NFL season, the quarterback battle has taken an intriguing turn. Tyler Shough, the undrafted rookie, has impressed coaches and fans alike with his strong performance in the preseason, outshining former South Carolina star Spencer Rattler in their head-to-head competition. While Shough has shown flashes of potential, the quarterback situation in New Orleans remains a major question mark as they head into the regular season.

Shough’s performance has been more than just a pleasant surprise. With poise in the pocket and a steady hand at the helm, he has showcased accuracy and command in crucial moments. His composure has drawn praise from Saints head coach Dennis Allen, who has acknowledged the rookie’s growth since the start of training camp. However, despite Shough's strong showing, it’s clear that the team’s future at the position is still in limbo.

On the other hand, Rattler, who was initially considered the front-runner for the starting job, has had a more inconsistent preseason. Although Rattler has the experience and pedigree from his time in college, his inability to string together a series of solid performances has raised concerns about his readiness to lead the Saints offense. Many have questioned whether he can handle the pressure of leading a franchise with such a storied history of quarterback play.

As the Saints continue to evaluate both quarterbacks, the team’s outlook for the 2025 season remains uncertain. While Shough has certainly made a case for himself, the lack of clarity at the position leaves the Saints facing a potentially rocky road ahead. Fans and analysts alike will be watching closely as the team makes its final decision, but one thing is clear: the quarterback competition in New Orleans is far from over.