Scheana Shay says husband Brock Davies’ cheating was ‘karma’ for Eddie Cibrian affair

   

Brock Davies cheated on Scheana Shay — and she’ll be the first to admit that her husband’s infidelity “really felt like … karma.”

The “Vanderpump Rules” alum reflected on her own affair in 2006 with then-married Eddie Cibrian while discussing Davies’ scandal with Us Weekly in an interview published Wednesday.

“Did I deserve [to be cheated on]?” Shay, 40, asked. “No, but I told myself that I did.”

Scheana Shay and Brock Davies via Instagram in July 2025

Scheana Shay admitted Brock Davies’ affair felt like “karma.” scheana/Instagram

Scheana Shay in June 2025

The “Vanderpump Rules” alum had an affair with Eddie Cibrian in 2006. Getty Images for Juicy Scoop with Heather McDonald

The reality star noted that she has worn a “scarlet letter for so long” and is regularly called a “home-wrecking whore” online for her past relationship with Cibrian.

Shay defended herself for being the actor’s “booty call” while he was married to Brandi Glanville, explaining, “I was lied to by a 33-year-old man when I was 21, fresh out of college. I feel like people tend to forget that.

“Looking back, were there red flags? Absolutely,” she continued. “I was leading with my heart and not my brain.”

 

Brandi Glanville and Eddie Cibrian in May 2009

The actor was married to Brandi Glanville at the time. WireImage

Scheana Shay via Instagram

“Did I deserve [to be cheated on]?” Shay asked in an Us Weekly interview Wednesday. “No, but I told myself that I did.” scheana/Instagram

The Bravolebrity does, however, “regret opening up to the media about” her time with the now-52-year-old “Sunset Beach” alum, which she called an “extremely immature and extremely irresponsible” choice.

“I wasn’t thinking about his wife and toddlers at home,” she admitted. “People like to say that I make everything about me — this was an instance where I was only thinking about myself.”

Shay noted, “Lo and behold, look what my husband did to me.”

Scheana Shay, Brock Davies and daughter via Instagram in December 2024

The Bravolebrity revealed last week that Davies cheated while she was pregnant with their daughter, Summer. scheana/Instagram

Scheana Shay and Brock Davies via Instagram

He didn’t confess to the betrayal for years. scheana/Instagram

The “Valley” star revealed last week in an excerpt of her upcoming memoir, “My Good Side,” that Davies had an affair while she was pregnant with their daughter, Summer, in 2021.

The 35-year-old did not tell Shay about his betrayal until Tom Sandoval’s cheating scandal went viral two years later — and Shay “went back and forth” about including it in her book.

“It started as absolutely not,” she explained to Us Weekly. “It was an eight-month conversation. After several therapy sessions and really talking about it, we decided that this book would be inauthentic if we didn’t put it all in.”

Scheana Shay and Brock Davies via Instagram in June 2025

Shay said on Wednesday that she “100 percent” would have dumped him if they did’t have a child. scheana/Instagram

Scheana Shay and Brock Davies via Instagram in March 2025

She has since forgiven her husband, which takes “work every single day.” scheana/Instagram

Shay clarified that she and Davies were “both … a little bit” on the fence.

Nevertheless, she decided, “I’d rather it come out in my words because, unfortunately, there was another person involved in this situation, and at any point in time, she could come forward.”

The woman, who has not been identified, was someone Davies knew previously and reconnected with at a F45 gym.

Shay “100 percent without a doubt would have left” her partner over the indiscretion if they did not have a 4-year-old.

Scheana Shay and Brock Davies in May 2025

The “Valley” star acknowledged to the outlet that she will “forever have insecurities.” Rachpoot/INSTARimages

Scheana Shay and Brock Davies at August 2022 wedding in Mexico

She and Davies, who wed in 2022, are planning to welcome another child via surrogate. HEM / BACKGRID

Her forgiveness has taken therapy and “work every single day,” with Shay deciding she “can’t let [Davies’] past define” him and make him “wear that for the rest of his life.”

She continued, “I will forever have insecurities. Just the other day, I saw him swipe and delete a text, and I’m like, ‘What was that?’ … But I genuinely believe he would never do anything like that again.”

The couple, who have been married since 2022, are now “slowly taking steps” to expand their family via surrogacy.