SHOCK TWIST: Carly’s Adoptive Parents BEG Catelynn & Tyler to Take Her Back — “We Made a Mistake!

🔥💣 “They Want Her Back Now?” — Teen Mom’s Catelynn & Tyler Allegedly Asked to Reclaim Carly After Shocking Plea From Adoptive Parents! 😱👶

Reality TV just got realer than ever.

In a shocking twist no one saw coming, Teen Mom stars Catelynn Lowell and Tyler Baltierra are reportedly at the center of a private storm — one that could flip their emotional adoption journey upside down. According to alleged insiders close to the couple, Carly’s adoptive parents have reached out in tears, asking Catelynn and Tyler if they would consider taking Carly back — citing “emotional challenges” and “parenting fatigue.”

“We did what we thought was right… but we’re struggling,” a source close to the adoptive family allegedly said in leaked texts. “She asks about her birth parents. She wants to know why she’s not with them.”

This bombshell directly contradicts the narrative fans have followed for years — that the open adoption was stable, healthy, and carefully navigated. Now, speculation is running wild: Was Carly kept from her birth parents all this time not to protect her — but to control the story?

👀 Social media is split.
Some fans are demanding answers from the adoptive parents, accusing them of “gatekeeping” Carly from her real family. Others argue this is exactly why adoption boundaries exist — and Catelynn and Tyler should “move on and let go.”

Meanwhile, neither party has confirmed nor denied the alleged plea — but a cryptic post from Tyler reading “You never know what’s really going on behind closed doors” has only poured fuel on the fire.

Is Carly on the verge of being reunited with the parents who gave her up to give her more?

Or is this just another manipulation tactic in a long, heartbreaking game of control?

One thing’s for sure: this story is far from over.