Season 4 was a turning point for Star Trek: Voyager. There was a notable boost in ratings between Voyager seasons 3 and 4, and the story generally reflects that. Season 4 brought the Borg to Voyager as major antagonists, and the reintroduction of one of Star Trek's most terrifying enemies immediately raised the stakes for the USS Voyager. But whereas the Borg on Star Trek: The Next Generation had been intermittent antagonists, appearing in only 6 episodes, Voyager turned a Borg drone into a member of the crew.
Perhaps the single biggest change between Star Yrek: Voyager seasons 3 and 4 was swapping Jennifer Lien's telepathic Ocampa, Kes, for Jeri Ryan's iconic former drone, Seven of Nine. Seven of Nine served as a foil for Captain Kathryn Janeway (Kate Mulgrew), revealing more about the occasionally isolated captain's inner life than almost any other character on Star Trek: Voyager. On the whole, Voyager broadened the scope of both its character choices and external conflicts in season 4, adding a whole new dimension to the growing show.
10"Omega Directive"
Star Trek: Voyager Season 4, Episode 21
In "Omega Directive," Star Trek: Voyager introduced one of the most interesting pieces of lore to Star Trek's canon: the mysterious and highly charged Omega particles that are so deadly that Starfleet trains all captains to destroy them immediately. The simple fact that every single Starfleet captain has had knowledge of Omega since the 23rd century and has had to keep it secret from their senior officers immediately adds nuance and complexity to every Star Trek captain's relationship with their first officers.
9"Scorpion Part 2"
Star Trek: Voyager Season 2, Episode 1
"Scorpion Part 2" is Star Trek: Voyager season 4's premiere, concluding season 3's cliffhanger. "Scorpion Part 2" made it immediately clear that the stakes would be higher than ever in season 4 and that Voyager's characters would rise to the occasion. The episode serves as a great introduction to Seven of Nine, framing her firmly as a member of the Borg Collective with no desire for individuality. Unlike Jonathan Del Arco's Hugh in Star Trek: The Next Generation, Seven of Nine had no desire to be known as an individual.
Star Trek: Voyager's season 4 premiere also created a great conflict between Captain Janeway and Commander Chakotay. As the episode's title suggests, Commander Chakotay thought the Borg Collective was fundamentally untrustworthy whereas Captain Janeway thought a temporary alliance was possible. As a result of Captain Janeway's trucem], Voyager fired shots in the Collective’s war with Species 8472, an act that would be unthinkable under Starfleet protocol in the Alpha Quadrant. The only reason this episode doesn't rank higher is that it was more of a set-up for later Voyager episodes than a narrative in and of its own right.
8"Revulsion"
Star Trek: Voyager Season 4, Episode 5
In many ways, Star Trek: Voyager's holographic Doctor (Robert Picardo) is a perfect inverse of TNG's Lt. Commander Data (Brent Spiner). Both are artificial lifeforms searching to grow beyond their programming and become more human, but Data's journey is centered on emotions - a quality that the Doctor has in spades. "Revulsion" offers a different foil for the Doctor's personal journey, in the form of the holographic Maintenance Unit, Dejaren (Leland Orser). As a result, "Revulsion" gives a great view into the Doctor’s psyche, and what the difference between biological and holographic life in the Delta Quadrant is like.
On top of these character insights, "Revulsion" is also an extremely well-written episode of Star Trek: Voyager. Dejaren is a genuinely scary villain, building tension in nearly every scene, and nearly killing Lt. B'Elanna Torres (Roxann Dawson) in the episode's climax. The only drawback to an otherwise nearly perfect episode is the episode's B-plot of Ensign Harry Kim (Garrett Wang) attempting to seduce Seven of Nine. These moments of comic relief ultimately clash with the horror-movie tone of the rest of the episode.
7"The Killing Game"
Star Trek: Voyager Season 4, Episodes 18 & 19
It’s fun and tense to see the USS Voyager's tactical officer, Lt. Tuvok (Tim Russ), fighting with a revolver, while Captain Janeway receives hidden messages on wine bottles. Outside the holodecks, the Doctor has some genuinely heroic moments that would be impossible in most other episodes of Star Trek: Voyager. And, as a cherry on top of an excellent episode, seeing Neelix (Ethan Philiips) as a drunken Klingon warrior swapping battle stories is genuinely hilarious. While "The Killing Game" may not be the single most substantive episode of Star Trek: Voyager, it is one of those episodes that is a joy to watch from beginning to end.
6"One"
Star Trek: Voyager Season 4, Episode 25
In "One," Seven of Nine is the only person who can remain conscious as the USS Voyager passes through a toxic nebula. From the first moments of the episode, Seven is forced to put her earlier growth into practice and be truly alone for the first time in her life. In the episode's culmination, Seven of Nine chooses to turn off life support in order to keep the rest of Voyager's crew safe in stasis. In "One," Seven of Nine is willing to sacrifice herself for Voyager, and the amount of growth from "Scorpion" to this moment is mind-boggling.
5"Scientific Method"
Star Trek: Voyager Season 4, Episode 7
Captain Janeway totally shuts down any attempt at ethical equivocation by flying the ship between two pulsars, and it is the perfect conclusion for the episode.
In the climax of the episode, the aliens and Captain Janeway have a direct confrontation, where they point out that the medical knowledge, they gain from Voyager will save many lives, even if it comes at the cost of the crew. While Captain Jean-Luc Picard (Patrick Stewart) or Captain Christopher Pike (Anson Mount) might have attempted to negotiate a solution, Captain Janeway makes the awesome choice to force the aliens' hands. Captain Janeway totally shuts down any attempt at ethical equivocation by flying the ship between two pulsars, and it is the perfect conclusion for the episode.
4"Mortal Coil"
Star Trek: Voyager Season 4, Episode 12
The episode ends with Naomi asking Neelix for a bedtime story, literally pulling Neelix back from the brink, in an incredibly touching display of the beauty of life. While the episode does not pull any punches - Neelix does not explicitly regain his faith by the end - "Mortal Coil" nevertheless delivers an emotionally satisfying ending. Simply put, "Mortal Coil" is a triumph. The only reason it does not rank even higher on this list is that Star Trek: Voyager season 4 is full of triumphant episodes.
3"Hope And Fear"
Star Trek: Voyager Season 4, Episode 26
But "Hope and Fear" has more than one excellent detail, making it immediately iconic. The reason Arturis (Ray Wise) wants to get Voyager assimilated by the Borg is that he blames them for his own species' assimilation, and he's sort of right. When Captain Janeway helped the Borg win against Species 8472, she inadvertently made it possible for the Collective to devote resources towards assimilating Arturis's species. Having a callback to "Scorpion" immediately takes "Hope and Fear" to the next level, and forcing Seven of Nine to confront her past as a drone is excellent.
2"Nemesis"
Star Trek: Voyager Season 4, Episode 4
I wish it were as easy to stop hating as it was to start.
But it is the conclusion of "Nemesis" that puts it at the top of this list. After Commander Chakotay has been rescued and has been shown that everything he experienced on the planet's surface was a lie, Captain Janeway brings in one of the Kradin so that they might thank him. But Commander Chakotay finds that he still cannot trust them, reflecting, "I wish it were as easy to stop hating as it was to start." "Nemesis" offers a deeply convincing example of the power of propaganda, and it drags the audience along for every second of it.