The Butler Did It?! Wild Y&R Fan Theory Sparks Frenzy Over Poison Plot & Colin’s Shocking Return!

Photo Credit: JPI Studios.

The Young and the Restless has always been a masterclass in jaw-dropping twists, but one fan, Marvin Sanders, thinks they’ve cracked a storyline so wild it could send Genoa City into total chaos. Could it be true? Did the butler really try to poison Caine…only for Damien to take the deadly sip instead? Buckle up because this fan theory will have you clutching your pearls.

Colin’s Revenge and the Butler’s Grudge

Here’s how Marvin’s theory goes: Damien’s (Jermaine River) shocking poisoning wasn’t just an accident. The real target was Cain (Billy Flynn), and it all leads back to the one man nobody suspects…the butler. According to Sanders, this quiet servant has been harboring a deep resentment against Cain, not for anything Cain did, but for something Colin (Tristan Rogers) pulled back in the day.

WATCH NOW: The drama’s live! Watch the SoapHub Says podcast now!

Apparently, Colin’s messy past left the butler’s family in ruins, and now the man in white gloves wants payback. Oh, and that knife – well, why not take someone all the way out when you’re already halfway there! Talk about a slow burn!

But wait, there’s more. Our dear fan is speculating that Colin isn’t even dead. That’s right – he’s alive, lurking in the shadows, and letting even Cain believe he’s six feet under. Why? Because Colin’s dramatic flair couldn’t resist one last game. In a delicious twist, some believe Colin will swoop in at the eleventh hour to rescue Cain from murder charges…only to unleash even more chaos.

Murder, Mystery, and the Ultimate Plot Twist

If this theory proves true, it would be one of the boldest plays Y&R has pulled in years. The idea of the butler orchestrating an elaborate revenge scheme adds a layer of classic soap mystery we’ve been craving. Plus, bringing Colin back from the dead would send shockwaves through Genoa City.

READ MORE: Forget who Colin is? Refresh your memory here!

So, is this Marvin Sanders’ fan theory too outrageous to be real or exactly the kind of shocking twist Y&R thrives on? We’ll be watching every smirk, side-eye, and serving tray for clues!

Got a wild soap prediction? Email [email protected] and you could spark our next buzz-worthy discussion.