The Valley’s Michelle Saniei Unfollows Boyfriend Aaron Nosler and Deletes His Photos From IG Page Sparking Breakup Rumors

Michelle Saniei has sparked rumors of a split from boyfriend Aaron Nosler.

On the heels of this week’s finale episode of The Valley season two, Michelle, 36, unfollowed Aaron, whom she began dating in early 2024, shortly after splitting from ex-husband Jesse Lally, 45, and removed photos of him from her Instagram feed.

On July 23, The Bravo Investigator took notice of the change in Michelle’s account, asking, “Is it the eyes???” as it shared a couple of screenshots of her page.

Around the same time, Bravo and Cocktails mentioned the social media moves on its own page, adding that Aaron would reportedly not be included in production on the upcoming third season of The Valley.

“It appears Michelle unfollowed Aaron but he’s still following her,” the Instagram fan page explained. “And we heard today Aaron isn’t filming The Valley season [three]…”

News of Michelle and Aaron’s potential split comes just months after she confirmed she’d moved in with her partner. 

During an Instagram Q&A with her fans and followers in May, Michelle shared that she and her five-year-old daughter Isabella, whom she shares with Jesse, had relocated from their former home to Aaron’s place after her lease ran out in March.

“I moved into Aaron’s about two months ago …. I had my apartment for a year, and my lease was up, and we just all talked about it, and it was just the right time and the right decision,” she revealed. “Isabella actually was the one that kept saying, ‘Why don’t we move in here? What are we doing in this apartment down the road? Why don’t we just live here?’”

The Valley‘s season two reunion begins airing next Tuesday, July 27, at 8/7c on Bravo.