The Yankees are headed straight to the American League Division Series. A huge win of the American League East got the Bronx Bombers into the bracket, and the best record in the league. Unfortunately, the Yankees are now back into a scramble for a first baseman.
For the second time this season, veteran first baseman Anthony Rizzo is back on the injured list. This time around, Rizzo fractured two fingers when he was hit by a pitch against the Pittsburgh Pirates.
The Yankees are keeping the Rizzo off the injured list for now, with a slight sense of optimism for a speedy return. But the reality is, he may not be back in time for the ALDS.
Loss of Yankees First Baseman Anthony Rizzo Could Hurt Them in the ALDS
Rizzo has not been the most productive version of himself lately, however, his performance after his return was a pleasant surprise. The first baseman did not play all of July and August. He made his return in September, when he played the best he had since early 2023.
The slugger recuperated from injury, slashing a .247/.345/.315. He recorded 18 hits with seven runs batted in. These numbers were not extravagant, but he played a steady hand in securing victories for New York. His lefty bat with a dependable defense is still much needed in the Yankee lineup.
Two Options to Replace Rizzo at First
Rizzo is expected to return soon. Whether that’s midway through the ALDS or after, the Yankees still have a contingency plan for a first baseman. As backup options, New York its prospect first baseman Ben Rice along with a utility infielder, Oswaldo Cabrera.
Rice was the original option to play first when Rizzo went on the injured list the first time. This recall seems to be full circle for the Yankees. Cabrera on the other hand is a utility man who has minimal time at the position but has some experience and the confidence to play first.
Replacements Need to Pull Their Weight
Rice did not get consistent time in the big leagues after getting called up. However, the high-ranking prospect got a fair taste of the pace of the majors. One goal he should adopt quickly is the adjustment to that pace, both offensively and defensively.
Defensively, Rice has a .997 fielding percentage in 49 game appearances and 41 starts. He has 273 putouts as well as 14 assists and 21 double plays. The rookie is clearly not afraid of the baseball and secures the right side of the infield with confidence.
Rice recorded 178 plate appearances and slashed .171/.264/.349. He launched seven home runs and drove in 23 RBI, all on 26 hits.
What is the key to success for Rice? At the plate, it’s a hard contact approach. His lefty bat often makes healthy contact, and if he gets into advantageous counts, he’ll find his pitch to drive up the middle.
Oswaldo Cabrera is a switch hitter who may choose to work his bat from the left side. This will ensure he fills his role in the lineup, given his poor performance from the right side. Cabrera totaled a slash of .247/.296/.365 this sesason. He also recorded eight home runs and 36 RBI on 74 hits.
Cabrera is also an athlete with some speed on the basepaths. His expectation as a player is to be a playmaker, whether it is on the base paths, at first base, or with the bat.
