Eagles Selectively Standing Tall on Their Moral High Ground

Eagles' Howie Roseman Takes Bold Stand Against Violence Toward Women — But Critics Question Consistency

The Philadelphia Eagles are riding high after their dominant Super Bowl LIX victory over the Kansas City Chiefs, but a recent viral clip of GM Howie Roseman has brought attention to more than just their on-field success.

In a March 4 appearance on The McShay Show, Roseman made headlines for stating that the Eagles have a nonnegotiable stance against signing players with histories of violence against women — a hardline policy reportedly set by owner Jeffrey Lurie.

“For one, like violence against women… it’s just not for us. I won’t even watch them. It’s a deal-breaker,” Roseman said.

He added that he wants to feel comfortable having his children around players in the locker room — a sentiment that resonated with fans praising the team’s moral stance. But while the message sounds admirable, it’s also sparked some debate about the Eagles' consistency when applying their values.

The Jalen Carter Complication

Just months before the 2023 NFL Draft, then-Georgia DT Jalen Carter was involved in a tragic street racing incident that left two people dead. Carter was later sentenced to 12 months probation, fined, and ordered to complete 50 hours of community service.

Despite this, the Eagles traded up to draft Carter with the ninth overall pick.

Critics argue that while Carter's incident didn't involve violence against women, it was still serious — reckless behavior with fatal consequences. Some have questioned how this aligns with the "moral absolute" Roseman described.

A Double Standard?

Roseman and the Eagles seem to apply hard limits on certain character concerns while taking a case-by-case approach to others. While Roseman's zero-tolerance policy on violence against women is commendable, others believe blanket bans can overlook nuance — especially in a world where false accusations exist and legal outcomes vary.

Ultimately, the Eagles are building a team with strong values and a winning culture. But as the Carter situation shows, the moral lines they draw aren’t always perfectly straight.

One thing is clear: Philadelphia is committed to doing things their way — on and off the field.