The Indianapolis Colts have three games left in their season. As it currently stands, the franchise has failed once again.
Outside of the fact that the team will not win the AFC South and their playoff chances being out of their control, they are leaving this season with the same question that they had entering the season. Is Anthony Richardson our franchise quarterback?
AR’s season last year was a failure because of injury. This season is a failure for a variety of reasons.
- Lack of consistency as a passer
- Explosive plays have not been as prevalent
- Questions about preparation and dedication towards the job
Item one of those three was expected. Richardson was coming off of shoulder surgery, did not get a full season of practice with his receivers a season ago, and was already questioned as a passer. The other two are surprises.
Part of the reason why Richardson was so tantalizing as a prospect was his dual threat capability, athleticism, and arm strength. Those explosive plays in the pass, or run, game have been too few and far between in 2024. Can Richardson be blamed for his shortcomings this season, or is it a combination of other issues?
There haven’t been a ton of games this season where Indianapolis was at full strength. Ryan Kelly, Michael Pittman Jr., Jonathan Taylor, Josh Downs, Braden Smith, Will Fries, and Bernhard Raiman have all missed time this year. Alec Pierce might be added to that list as he is currently in the NFL’s concussion protocol.
When those guys have been out there, they haven’t helped Richardson much. The wide receivers are still struggling to create separation, dropping passes, and seemingly struggle with coming down with contested catches. Downs has been one of the lone bright spots for the Colts offense. Pierce has flashed, but he hasn’t been noticed since his 134-yard performance against the Jaguars in week six. With the offensive line injuries, the team hasn’t been able to create running lanes for Taylor to break off some big runs to make the pass game easier. Finally, the tight ends have been lackluster. Kylen Granson, Mo Alie-Cox, Andrew Ogletree, and Will Mallory have not produced in any capacity.
The last person who has failed Richardson might be the most surprising. The Indianapolis Colts head coach, Shane Steichen. There was a lot of praise for Steichen with how he was a key figure in the developments of Justin Herbert, Philip Rivers, and Jalen Hurts. It doesn’t seem like he has had the same success with Richardson just yet. Prior to benching Richardson, Steichen was utilizing Richardson’s mobility. There weren’t a ton of designed runs, boot legs, or plays involving his legs.
